Skip to the content

Insuring the Greater Pittsburgh Area Since 1960

Insurance Services
About Us
Policy Service
Contact Us

Home > Customer Reviews

Customer Reviews

BS
Venetia, PACustomer since Aug 2018
“I’ve had Erie insurance through McElhinny for almost 30 years for auto and almost 20 years for home owners. It’s been very rare that I’ve had to make any claims, but when I have it was always been an easy and satisfying experience.”
JM
Jeffrey M., Pittsburgh, PACustomer since Jul 2012
“Office staff is always very helpful. If they can’t answer a question, they call back expediently with the answer. Also, quality insurance. Never had an issue with any claims. ”
AP
White Oak, PACustomer since Feb 2014
“That you’ve always treat us like family. Which is an awesome feeling. When you’re looking for insurance needs for your family.
Thanks Tim and Tom McElhinny and Family.
”
MW
Mark W., Kentfield, CACustomer since Feb 2018
“Love working with Cathy! She goes over and above.”
DM
Dean M., Pittsburgh, PACustomer since Sep 2015
“Any time I have a question Kathy always is there with the answer. She is so helpful and never rushes to get off the phone. She is an asset to the company. ”
JP
Lawrence, PACustomer since Jun 2012
“Any time I’ve had a question or needed information, the staff at McElhinny’s has always been very courteous and helpful.”
DM
Pittsburgh, PACustomer since Nov 2013
“Easy to deal with and reasonably priced.”
RD
Ronald D., Elizabeth, PACustomer since Apr 2015
“Very friendly staff. Great coverage for a good rate!”
DB
Derek B., south Park, PACustomer since May 2011
“You are very helpful and actually discuss what will happen in insurance situations. ”
SM
Shawn M., Allison Park, PACustomer since Sep 2017
“When I have a question or need a document Tom’s response time is outstanding! I had to wait sometimes a week to two weeks when I needed something from our last insurance company. And Tom has what I need within a few hours. ”
AR
Alison R., Pittsburgh, PACustomer since Apr 2018
“Your office staff is wonderful. They are always so helpful when I have questions. I appreciate their expertise and kindness. ”
FR
Frank R., Bethel Park, PACustomer since Jun 2016
“Great prices on classic insurance.”
VK
Pittsburgh, PACustomer since Dec 2011
“Every time I call with questions I always get my answer. The women who assist me are always friendly and helpful. I have never had a poor experience and I have been a customer for 15 years. ”
RP
Jefferson Hills, PACustomer since Aug 2013
“responsive to all call and to any questions we have had throughout the time you have been our Agent. ”
DS
David S., WHITE OAK, PACustomer since Sep 2015
“I strongly recommend Erie for their superior customer service and loyalty. I am very happy with the rates for all their insurance policies. I appreciate the polite and courteous answer’s to questions that I have at times. During the very few incidents that I had over the years they have always been there for me. I strongly recommend them over any other insurance company out there. Keep up the great work and thank you for being here.”

Previous Page
1
…
15
…
17
Next Page

McElhinny Insurance Agency

Rated 5 out of 5 based on 114 rated reviews.

We Want Your Opinion!

Pittsburgh Insurance Quotes

Name*
Email*
Phone (Optional)
Select Type of Insurance*
Phone
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Δ

About Us

About Us
Meet Our Staff
Our Insurance Carriers
Customer Reviews
Insurance Blog

Insurance

Auto Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
Life & Health Insurance

Policy Service

Policy Service Center
File A Claim
Online Billing & Payments
Policy Change Request
Annual Insurance Checklist

Connect With Us

Google Maps Logo (opens in new tab)Yelp Logo (opens in new tab)Facebook Logo (opens in new tab)X Logo (opens in new tab)LinkedIn Logo (opens in new tab)YouTube Logo (opens in new tab)Instagram Logo (opens in new tab)Nextdoor Logo (opens in new tab)

Get Directions (opens in new tab)

McElhinny Insurance Agency

5624 Brownsville Road
Second Floor
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15236

Phone: (412) 650-5700

Fax: (412) 650-5782

Office Hours
Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
Sat-Sun: Closed

McElhinny Insurance Agency Provides Auto Insurance, Classic Car Insurance, Home Insurance, Small Business Insurance & Life Insurance to All of Pennsylvania, Including Pittsburgh, Jefferson Hills, and Mt. Lebanon.

© Copyright 2025, McElhinny Insurance Agency | Privacy Statement | Accessibility Statement | Login

Website Builder Platform(opens in new tab)