- Insurance Services
- Auto, Home & Personal Insurance
- Classic Car Insurance
- Business Insurance
- Business Interruption Insurance
- Business Owners Package Insurance
- Commercial Auto Insurance
- Commercial Property Insurance
- Commercial Umbrella Insurance
- General Liability Insurance
- Hotel & Motel Hospitality Insurance
- Manufacturers Insurance
- Professional Liability (E&O) Insurance
- Surety Bonds
- Workers' Compensation Insurance
- - View All Business
- Life & Health Insurance
- About Us
- Policy Service
- Contact Us
Customer Reviews
- DKDan K., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I have been with Tim for around 45 years now. I signed my first policy when I bought a boat back in 1975. Erie was one of the few companies that would sell speedboat insurance. (Can you believe that?) My present homeowners and vehicle insurance company refused to cover my ski boat!
I switched my home owners and vehicle insurance to Erie shortly after. Tim was great in reviewing my current policies and recommending what type of coverage I should have. Much to my surprise the price was cheaper than what I was paying from another company.
Since then Tim has helped with additional policies for all the toys I purchased as I moved forward in my life. ( Summer camp, Rental Property, 5 Quads, Pontoon, 2 Side by Sides and now our riverfront retirement home.
Fortunately I have had not had many claims, but the claims I did have, Tim assisted me in handling them quickly and professionally.
This year, Erie reduced the price of my policy due to Covid.
Through the years I have compared my policies with other insurance companies.
Erie was always the best.
While Erie Insurance always fit my needs, it was Tim’s dedication and help that kept me with McElhinny Insurance.Thanks Tim!”
- KSKaren S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I have been with McElhinny Insurance for 35 years. Very professional, very prompt, always understanding and kind. Always a positive, fair experience.”
- NRNadine R., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Very professional and attentive to your needs. I have been a client for 50+ years.”
- VAvito a., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- Cassandra H., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Very personal and friendly customer service. Definitely not a number! Also, Cathy is proactive in finding applicable discounts, etc. It’s nice to feel valued.”
- Victoria L., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- CCChupa C., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- LGLori G., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- JPJeffrey P., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Denise and her team are great to work with. They are very responsive and will work hard to earn your business. I left another insurance company after 20 years and came to the McElhinny Agency and it was one of the best moves I have made.”
- Mary M., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Been dealing with with agency for over 20 years and have never had a problem that they did not respond to quickly and efficiently.”
- PiperGator, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- JCJeff C., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“As far as I’m concerned Cathy Schuessler did everything right. Asked the right questions and recommend the proper coverages and deductibles to siut my families needs. I’ve already referred your a few people to her. It was a pleasure working with a knowledgeable professional. Thanks again!”
- ACAngela C., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- GRGary R., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I highly recommend McElhinney Insurance. I’ve been a customer for over 30+ years. It started with Erie Car Insurance – they’re the best because they don’t use third-party parts to repair your car – and it expanded into home owners and life insurance. The McElhinney staff is exceptional – they thoroughly answer all my questions and provide the appropriate advise and guidance. Annually, I receive a call to review all my policies – we make the needed changes (and even reduce coverage when appropriate). They’re a great company to work with!”
- MLMary L., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tim was very professional and easy to talk to. He knows his business well. I liked dealing with him.”